By Jesse Dougherty
Even though the start of the 2013 MLB season is still months away, fans in Cleveland have something to look forward to, and that is the arrival of manager Terry Francona to the Progressive Field dugout.
![]() |
(AP Photo/Dave Richard) |
Since finishing first in the AL Central in 2007, and later losing to Francona’s Red Sox in the American League Championship Series, the Indians have had a hard time capturing success that has been rather rare in the franchise’s history. Since ’07, the club’s best finish was in 2008, 81-81, which was just enough to earn them third place in the division.
And they haven’t finished with a winning record since.
We all know the story with the Indians, it all happens like clockwork at the start of each baseball season. They come out of the gates hot, hitting the ball, winning close games, pitching well enough, and cracking the MLB headlines by raising questions like, “could this be the Indians year?”
Then the All-Star break rolls around and the Indians are annually grounded, and reminded that they don’t spend near enough money to compete with the league’s best, and young, potential talent is exactly that; young potential talent.
A roaring start turns into a roaring fan base, and the Tribe slides down the mountain they once sat atop.
Manager Eric Wedge was around in ’07, the club’s best year in a lot of years, and that earned him a prolonged stay despite a string of losing campaigns. After Wedge’s departure after the 2009 season, the Indians brought in Manny Acta, an experiment that almost lasted three years until Acta was fired with six games left in 2012.
After interim manager Sandy Alomar Jr. closed the year and helped the Indians clinch a 68-94 record, the search for a new manager began but wouldn’t last long. After a year on ESPN, Terry Francona got the job.
Francona joined the Red Sox in 2003, on the heels of an ALCS loss to the Yankees (remember Aaron Boone, Wakefield, and the knuckleball that would have hung forever), and led Boston to a World Series title the next year. While in Boston, Francona won that title in ’04, another in ’07, and never had a losing record at the end of the regular season.
So if he really never fell short, why’d he ever leave? Well Francona, who is well known for developing a sound clubhouse relationship with his team, seemed to lose control of the Red Sox in 2011. After a historic collapse that had them finish third in the AL East, reports surfaced that members of the pitching staff had been drinking beers on their off days, and that “ace” Josh Beckett made a lackluster effort to rehab an injury throughout the season.
The once player manager was now the face of a team that was disrespectful to the game, and Boston got rid of Francona and brought in militant Bobby Valentine to turn the ship around, and we all know how that turned out.
After a year as an analyst Francona decided to publicize himself as a manager once again, and that led him to Cleveland, where he hopes to be the manager that can sustain their success beyond the All-Star break.
A loyal fan base may be wondering why they are so loyal to a team that constantly disappointed. It is now Tito’s tribe, and the city of Cleveland is anxiously waiting to see what he will do with it.